Short answer: Jesus painting restoration fail
The Ecce Homo fresco, also known as the “Monkey Christ,” is a notorious example of a botched art restoration. The 2012 effort by an amateur artist named Cecilia Giménez went viral for its lack of skill and disregard for the original piece. Ironically, it ultimately gained popularity as a humorous internet meme.
Step by Step: What Went Wrong with the Jesus Painting Restoration
In 2012, a well-intentioned elderly woman from Spain attempted to “restore” a century-old painting of Jesus Christ in her local church. The resulting image was widely regarded as an abomination; the once serene and dignified portrait was transformed into something resembling a cartoon character with only vaguely human features.
So what went wrong? We can pinpoint several key errors that led to this disastrous restoration attempt.
1. Lack of Experience: Whilst it’s admirable for someone to volunteer their time to restore art, there are good reasons why professional conservators undergo years of training before they take on such work. This particular restoration project wasn’t tackled by anyone who had any formal experience and expertise in the subject matter–an early warning sign.
2. Failure to Consult Professionals: Restoration isn’t simply about slapping some paint onto a canvas or plaster surface; it involves sensitively navigating between preservation and enhancement goals whilst also respecting the artistic intent of the original piece. Anyone undertaking such work must proceed carefully using tested methods taken from hundreds of years worth of accumulated knowledge (and modern techniques). There is no substitute for consulting professionals when you aren’t sure what you’re doing!
3. Over-Confidence: It seems that our would-be restorer looked at this centuries old artwork covered with dirt and thought “I can clean that up”. Furthermore, she believed she could enhance it by increasingly adding pigment unintentionally changing its colour structure thus ruining delicate edges where tones blended seamlessly together in harmony making everything more coarse-grained looking like different images smashed together. All without paying any attention whatsoever to how each part related within itself composition-wise nor regards movement from left-to-right eye travel which impacts legibility – all seemingly were lost on her during these misguided attempts at improving things further exacerbating her initial mistakes listed above already beyond hope remediation.
4. Inadequate Tools & Equipment: Conservation labs usually have ultraviolet lamps, microscopes, and environmental controls to optimize light, temperature and humidity. None of these were used or had been available during the restoration; instead an old-fashioned brush was found on-hand being sufficient for this restorer’s desires- what might have worked in a different context is utterly unusable here when trying to restore centuries-old works without taking care that they’re restored exactly as-is using tested methods settled over years of trial-and-error alongside modern tech upgrades.
5. Lack of Respect for Artistic Integrity: The most important consideration which ultimately got forgotten by our painter friend here was respect not to their own artistic opinions, but rather upholding the original image’s intended meaning – where less is often better than more! This principle when consistently followed makes such drastic interventions unnecessary yet still can invite misunderstandings amongst inexperienced “restorers”.
Unfortunately, this situation frequently demonstrates what can happen when good intentions don’t line up with professional expertise guided by applicable knowledge from decades if not centuries worth experience gained through zealously conserving irreplaceable treasure troves of art all around world throughout time itself does yield incredibly valuable
Top FAQs About the Notorious Jesus Painting Restoration Fail
The Ecce Homo painting, also known as the “Notorious Jesus Painting” or the “Monkey Christ” is a restoration fail that made international headlines in 2012. The vandalized portrait of Jesus was given to amateur art restorer Cecilia Giménez by her local church in Borja, Spain with the hope that she could fix some damage to the fresco. However, once Giménez finished “restoring” the artwork, it became clear that this would go down as one of history’s worst attempts at art conservation.
In case you’ve been living under a rock for eight years and don’t know what we’re talking about; let’s get into some frequently asked questions about this infamous art disaster:
1) What happened exactly?
What initially began as an attempt to restore peeling paint on a century-old fresco of Christ turned into what looked like a cartoon monkey head painted over its original image. Needless to say, people were stunned.
2) Why did it become so famous worldwide?
After photos of four-legged pig-like creatures rapidly leaned towards notoriety on social media and news outlets everywhere (birds had even evolved nostrils on their beaks), people couldn’t help but share their thoughts regarding world-renowned preservation experts versus amateurs: should they learn from example?
3) Was any legal action taken?
No lawsuits have been filed against Cecilia due to the ‘before’ picture looking bad already since previous efforts hadn’t been successful either.
4) How does one obtain such poor skill when attempting basic drawing copies?
It is believed that Cecilia worked quickly, without preliminary sketches or carefully mapping out colors or laying them down patiently in layers. She just went straight for it – with disastrous results.
5) Is there still anything salvageable in regards to restoration processes done on the piece after Ms. Jimenez’ initial carelessness led us astray.
Quoting artist David Speed Elder here: “The painting was damaged before the restoration, and it’s now something new – not an original. But, in reality all that matters is what people think of the damage.” He further adds perhaps rather amusingly enough: “Art history is filled with such examples of artists painting over other artists’ work.”
6) Do They Have any Photos or Video Footage Left from Before Restoration?
“There are a few photos left but nothing really documented,” says Borja cultural council secretary Antonio Navarro.
7) Could better preventative measures have been set up beforehand if they knew Cecilia had one day hoped to undergo this kind of creative leap?
The then-81-year-old Giménez expressed remorse for her handiwork on numerous occasions. She notably addressed reporters earlier this year at a conference held by art historians throughout Europe at which she claimed responsibility for having performed her attempts without legal permission first.
In conclusion, while we’d all like to believe that our well-intentioned works would be met with success; sometimes they simply don’t hit the mark. There’s no denying that
Examining the Aftermath of the Jesus Painting Restoration Fail
In 2012, a small church in Spain called the Santuario de Misericordia attempted to restore a century-old painting of Jesus Christ. What they ended up achieving was nothing short of an absolute disaster- a failed restoration that went viral and became a worldwide joke.
The original painting depicted Christ wearing his crown of thorns while gazing upward with soft brown eyes before him. The smile on his face exuded warmth and compassion towards humanity, which is why it hurt all the more when we saw what happened during the abominable ‘restoration’ process.
After authorities investigated the incident under suspicion that untrained individuals had tampered with artwork of national heritage (which carries a fine or imprisonment), it emerged that an unsuspecting elderly woman named Cecilia Gimenez had volunteered her services for this daunting task. With no experience or know-how in restoring paintings whatsoever, she began repainting what was left behind in tatters – according to her recalling later “just like that”.
As you might expect from such an incompetent attempt at art conservation, chaos ensued: over fifty years worth of paint flaked off due to spray paints applied unevenly by mistargeted strokes. It was not long until social media users picked up on images showing how ridiculed and meme-worthy this crude rendition looked; after people shared photos online featuring various examples of poor workmanship covering everything from bubble-headed creatures resembling aliens instead replacing floral garlands intended adorning Adoración del Cordero pascual (Lamb Of God) frescoes – taken alongside their authentic counterparts – plus obvious challenges confronting attempts scrutinizing various symbolic details gone missing throughout final product design modifications would change authenticity beyond recognition anyway …It quickly became clear how sheer badness could generate controversy as easily as any other form artistic endeavorful endeavors–“bad” music videos spring immediately come into mind here!
But despite being regarded initially as vandalism rather than restoration following widespread ridicule globally—including Internet memes and deserved satire from respected humorists such as Stephen Colbert—reports emerged that the “ecce homo” (“Behold the man”) fresco mural painted by Emanuel Borja in 1930 so violently deteriorated due to ordeals of time decorating walls inside her local place worship- with this serving more as a decoration than actual painting possession interest historically – Gimenez’s restoration may be regarded nowadays especially among locals overarchingly embraced. Tourists even come sometimes out of curiosity how noticeably ignorant invasion produced fascination not seen before- one industry insider quotes visitor numbers remaining surprisingly sustained higher beyond paltry initial expectations, signaling able discern life-sustenance where there appeared none earlier.
While what took place that fateful day all those years ago initially resulted in endless jokes about an incredible botched job, something beautiful had eventually come out of it after all. Whether you regard Cecilia’s handiwork at Santuario de Misericordia as vandalism or art creation subsequent appreciation, her willingness to try despite having no qualifications shows anything is possible; maybe some unknown talents only need